Ruud van Nistelrooy vs Michael Owen: who will win the battle of the returning strikers this season?

Who would have thunk it? With Ruud van Nistelrooy on the brink of moving to Anfield , and Michael Owen now plying his trade at Old Trafford, a scenario that just five years ago would have been unthinkable could be a reality this January.

But are Manchester United or Liverpool getting more bang for their buck from these two old gunslingers? MirrorFootball takes a look...

What's left in the tank?
Both players names' seem to go hand in hand with the phrase "injury prone". Manchester United's original move for Van Nistelrooy was delayed by a year because of a knee injury, and the same problem kept him out for most of last season. He is getting back to full fitness now, but at 33-years-old he's never likely to be completely injury free again.

Owen has struggled with injuries for his entire career and, like Van Nistelrooy, had to be treated by Dr Richard "football's miracle worker" Steadman to avoid having his career ended completely in 2006. Has been fit since joining United and, at 29, he has the edge on Van Nistelrooy in age.

Verdict: Owen, just.

Who's the best box office?
Not that either of these teams really need anyone to put bums on seats, but the Dutchman is likely to have more pulling power at Liverpool than Michael Owen does at United. With goals a precious commodity at Anfield this season, Ruud could quickly find himself a hero for his prowess in front of the net - especially if he scores against United.

Owen has done his best - the injury time goal against Manchester City will help - but he still has to go some to win hearts and minds at Old Trafford.

Verdict: Van Nistelrooy

Who has the ex-factor?
Michael Owen is a traitor in the eyes of Kopites for his move to Old Trafford but will United fans care if Van Nistelrooy joins their arch rivals?

According to our scientific office poll of two, no, they won't. The untrammelled success enjoyed by United since the Dutchman left means they've barely had a chance even to miss him.

Verdict: Owen

Who can become a World Cup hero?
Van Nistelrooy is anxious to leave Real Madrid to get more first team action and ensure his World Cup place. Sound familiar?

Owen left the Bernabeu for exactly that reason in 2005 and look how that worked out for him. After limping out of the 2006 tournament after just a few minutes, and with Fabio Capello apparently preferring anyone but Owen up front for England, his chances of making South Africa are slim to none.

With half a season banging them in for Liverpool Van Nistelrooy could easily play his way into Holland's World Cup squad. Conversely, Owen's less than stellar performances for Man United's second string line-ups should ensure he's far below the likes of Jermain Defoe and Darren Bent come next summer.

Verdict: Van Nistelrooy

Who will get the most goals?
Owen currently has a four-goal head-start on Van Nistelrooy (and who knows - that could rise to as many as five by January), but with the extra playing time the Dutchman would surely get at Anfield, you'd have to think long and hard about betting against him. And besides, think of all those Europa League fixtures he'll be playing in...

Verdict: Van Nistelrooy

And the winner is...?
We all know Michael Owen loves the gee-gees, while Ruud just facially resembles one, but if we were of a betting bent then we'd have to go with Van the Man to win. By a nose.

Should the Van Nistelrooy transfer come off, then who do you think will be a bigger hit in the Premier League? Let us know by leaving a comment below...



Which classic football manager are you? Take our test

Follow MirrorFootball on Twitter for breaking news, the latest opinions and fun stuff throughout the day

Get the best priced tickets to the best games at Mirror Tickets.

Win two tickets to see Fulham vs Man City with Mirror Football.

Your comments

Related content

10 things you need to know about Jack Rodwell
    Bastian Schweinsteiger: 10 things you need to know about the Chelsea target, plus video of him in action
      Will Torres jump ship and join Chelsea?
        Champions League special - Martin Lipton rates the remaining eight runners and riders gunning for the European Cup
          10 things we learned from watching Barcelona vs Stuttgart
            Reds alert: 10 things Liverpool need to get right to beat Lille
              Liverpool archive special: See amazing unseen pictures of the 1984 and 2005 European Cup triumphs
                Fulham on the way out of Europe? Juve got to be joking!
                  St Patrick's Day special: See amazing unseen pictures of Irish football legends

                    Latest opinions

                    Blog

                    10 things you need to know about Jack Rodwell

                    Mirror Football Blog 17:31 18/03/10

                        By Mehreen KhanAs Chelsea look to freshen up their ageing squad, one man they've been linked with is... Read More+

                        Blog

                        Bastian Schweinsteiger: 10 things you need to know about the Chelsea target, plus video of him in action

                        Mirror Football Blog 15:15 18/03/10

                            By Mehreen KhanAs Chelsea seek to ease their Champions League exit pain with some retail therapy, na... Read More+

                            Blog

                            Will Torres jump ship and join Chelsea?

                            Mirror Football Blog 14:43 18/03/10

                                Smarting from Chelsea's latest Champions League exit, owner Roman Abramovich is said to be readying ... Read More+

                                Blog

                                3PM Extra: The best things we've found on the internet today - March 18, 2010

                                Football Banter 14:41 18/03/10

                                    OK, so you've done your wages betting on three-legged nags down in the west country and, consequentl... Read More+

                                    Blog

                                    Strawberry blond? Who are you kidding! The best Ginga XI of all-time

                                    Football Banter 13:15 18/03/10

                                        So, ladies and gentlemen, here it is... the best Ginga XI - EVER!In honour of Paul Scholes scoring h... Read More+

                                        Blog

                                        10 things you need to know about Marek Hamsik

                                        Football Spy 12:59 18/03/10

                                            Napoli's Marek Hamsik has been rated as one of Europe's hottest young prospects for a while now, reg... Read More+

                                            Column

                                            Unhappy Kop stars should learn that actions speak louder than words

                                            Liverpool 12:33 18/03/10

                                                News of Albert Riera wanting to quit Anfield, and his criticism of manager Rafael Benitez in an inte... Read More+

                                                Blog

                                                Champions League special - Martin Lipton rates the remaining eight runners and riders gunning for the European Cup

                                                Mirror Football Blog 12:01 18/03/10

                                                    So now it's down to eight, a rather different-looking elite to the one we had all expected.No Chelse... Read More+

                                                    Blog

                                                    10 things we learned from watching Barcelona vs Stuttgart

                                                    Mirror Football Blog 11:56 18/03/10

                                                        Barcelona turned in a masterclass of football last night as they eased into the Champions League qua... Read More+

                                                        Blog

                                                        Reds alert: 10 things Liverpool need to get right to beat Lille

                                                        Mirror Football Blog 11:31 18/03/10

                                                            Liverpool are facing a make-or-break Euro clash tonight (isn't every one of their games make-or-brea... Read More+

                                                            Blog

                                                            Liverpool archive special: See amazing unseen pictures of the 1984 and 2005 European Cup triumphs

                                                            Mirror Football Blog 10:13 18/03/10

                                                                And so, dear Liverpool fans, it is once more into the European breach. The Europa League might be so... Read More+

                                                                Blog

                                                                Transfer news, rumours and gossip from Thursday's papers

                                                                Football Spy 09:51 18/03/10

                                                                    From today's Daily Mirror:Chelsea planning dream team pairing of Drogba and Torres Abramovich will s... Read More+

                                                                    Does Carlo Ancelotti now have to win the title to keep his job?

                                                                    Blogs & Categories