The Carling Cup is football's equivalent to Betamax videos

When it comes to pointless and redundant creations, the Carling Cup is up there with the Sinclair C5 and Betamax videos.

No-one is interested in the Carling Cup anymore - if they ever were.

Managers don't like it and the top bosses see it as an irritation in an already overcrowded fixture list.

Their priorities are Premier League, Champions League, FA Cup and trailing in a distant fourth - the Carling Cup.

They play their stiffs and shrug their shoulders when they lose, which sums up how bothered they are about it.

I remember Fergie quipping "what a great result for Manchester United" when they lost at Ipswich in the late 90s because he could look forward to a few free midweeks.

The bosses of the Premier League's lesser lights don't even take it seriously and they also field weakened sides because their priority is staying up.

The fans couldn't care, as evidenced by the drop in gates when it's Carling Cup night.

It doesn't even generate any excitement, and who cares if Wolves reserves beat Manchester United reserves?

Unlike the FA Cup, can anyone actually remember a 'shock' from recent years?

The final is hardly a showpiece and last season's match between Tottenham and United was a snoozefest.

If the Football League really want a cup competition, then restrict it to their members. Don't include the Premier League clubs because few of them want to be in it anyway.

It might give the competition a new lease of life and give someone else a crack at Wembley rather than just Chelsea or United's reserves.

Fancy winning £3,000 for FREE this month? Play Mirror Football Streak for your chance to win cash prizes! Start predicting now!

williamhill.com

Your comments

Related content

Why George Osbourne could learn something from Moyes' cuts and spending in the transfer market
    Why David Moyes is perfectly entitled to be an Olympics spoilsport
      Why MotD treatment highlights just how far Everton have fallen
        Is Antonio Valencia now United's most important player?

          Latest opinions

          Blog

          What are the odds Suarez and Evra swap shirts at the final whistle? Derek McGovern's Bets of the Day

          Betting Blog 22:00 10/02/12

          The FA reckon Luis Suarez and Patrice Evra should shake hands when they come face to face on Saturda... Read More+

          Column

          United v Liverpool has always been spiky... but it used to be about football too

          Brian Reade 20:59 10/02/12

            We should have sacked Capello two years ago Why Moyes is the right man for Spurs  Those who think to... Read More+

            Column

            We should have sacked Capello two years ago

            Brian Reade 20:58 10/02/12

              United v Liverpool has always been spiky... but it used to be about football too Why Moyes is the ri... Read More+

              Column

              Why Moyes is the right man for Spurs

              Brian Reade 20:57 10/02/12

                United v Liverpool has always been spiky... but it used to be about football too  We should have sac... Read More+

                Blog

                Watch video of Sami Khedira and Lena Gercke's steamy GQ photo shoot

                Mirror Football Blog 15:52 10/02/12

                  It's a tough life being a top footballer part 3,876: poor old Sami Khedira. Not only is he forced to... Read More+

                  Blog

                  3PM Extra: Joe Hart's fart, when mascots attack and Turkish team's bus collides with express train

                  Football Banter 15:38 10/02/12

                    Presenting quality football videos from the interweb, daily at 3pm. Here's today's collection: 1) We... Read More+

                    Column

                    Why does snow and extreme weather bring out the best in football fans?

                    Ian Winwood 14:09 10/02/12

                      A few years ago, on the weekend before Christmas I went with my mum to see Barnsley play at Queens P... Read More+

                      Blog

                      Simon Bird's Premier League previews and predictions (Week 25)

                      Mirror Football Blog 12:09 10/02/12

                        'Arry'll put a smile on those poor England boys' faces. Yeah, 'Arry's a man manager. Arm round the s... Read More+

                        Blog

                        The Best XI Liverpool vs Manchester United games

                        Mirror Football Blog 11:25 10/02/12

                          The MirrorFootball Best XI is our new feature celebrating the very best of the beautiful game. Each ... Read More+

                          Blog

                          Why do Rooney and co want Redknapp to succeed Capello? He'll make playing for England fun again

                          Mirror Football Blog 00:00 10/02/12

                            Wayne Rooney and Rio Ferdinand have already taken to Twitter to say Harry Redknapp is the man they’d... Read More+

                            Blog

                            Why having a Football Association chairman with balls gives England hope for the future

                            Mirror Football Blog 23:00 09/02/12

                              For a man who just shot the sheriff, David ­Bernstein looked ­thoroughly unruffled. The FA chairman ... Read More+

                              Column

                              Redknapp will be a great England boss, but not before he leaves Spurs with a top, top parting gift

                              Robbie Savage 22:00 09/02/12

                                You would have thought Harry Redknapp will find it difficult to keep his eye on the ball. Every time... Read More+

                                Who should be England's next manager?

                                Latest columnists

                                Brian Reade

                                Brian Reade Read more from Brian Reade

                                Ian Winwood

                                Ian Winwood Read more from Ian Winwood

                                Robbie Savage

                                Robbie Savage Read more from Robbie Savage

                                James Nursey

                                James Nursey Read more from James Nursey

                                Mark Lawrenson

                                Mark Lawrenson Read more from Mark Lawrenson

                                Latest blogs

                                Watch video of Sami Khedira and Lena Gercke's steamy GQ photo shoot - Mirror Football Blog
                                  3PM Extra: Joe Hart's fart, when mascots attack and Turkish team's bus collides with express train - Football Banter
                                    Simon Bird's Premier League previews and predictions (Week 25) - Mirror Football Blog
                                      The Best XI Liverpool vs Manchester United games - Mirror Football Blog
                                        Why do Rooney and co want Redknapp to succeed Capello? He'll make playing for England fun again - Mirror Football Blog
                                          Why having a Football Association chairman with balls gives England hope for the future - Mirror Football Blog