Why Blues boss Alex McLeish could be set for a change of Hart over his No.1

Birmingham boss Alex McLeish faces a significant dilemma ahead of their trip to Liverpool on Monday in the Premier League.

Brum chief McLeish must decide whether to keep Maik Taylor in goal or recall on-loan Manchester City star Joe Hart.

England prospect Hart, 22, was ineligible to face his parent club, City, in Sunday's televised game.

And in his absence, Northern Ireland international Taylor, 38, performed admirably in the 0-0 draw on his first top-flight appearance of the campaign.

Now after witnessing a string of blunders from the error-prone Hart, most Brum fans want to see the dependable Taylor retain his place.

I was at Birmingham's training ground this week when McLeish held a Q&A with some young fans from Birmingham Children's Hospital.

And one lively youngster named George asked McLeish this very question about the keeper's jersey.

McLeish's response gave little away, as you would expect.

But I believe Taylor, who starred for Birmingham last season in the Championship, deserves to stay No.1.

And if I was a betting man, like most Premier League footballers, that is what I would put my money on.



Which classic football manager are you? Take our test

Follow MirrorFootball on Twitter for breaking news, the latest opinions and fun stuff throughout the day

Get the best priced tickets to the best games at Mirror Tickets.

Win two tickets to see Fulham vs Man City with Mirror Football.

Your comments

Related content

Has Randy Lerner really got value for money at Villa?
    Alex McLeish has proved to be Mr Motivator to keep Birmingham on track
      Hull fans should beware Derby's cautionary tale after Brown sacking
        My head says Hart should be England's World Cup No.1
          Villa fans can expect a committed Carew for the rest of the season
            Wolves' lack of quality signings mean Doyle deserves another Premier League club
              Martin O'Neill must learn the lessons from Carling Cup defeat
                McCarthy's Wolves will bare their teeth against Man United this weekend
                  By Eck, McLeish won't be bullied in the transfer market
                    Why Villa must drop Brad Guzan for the Carling Cup final

                      Latest opinions

                      Blog

                      Transfer news, rumours and gossip from Sunday's papers

                      Football Spy 11:55 21/03/10

                          Stories from today's Sunday Mirror:Spurs set to swoop for £7.5million West Ham star - ExclusiveJuven... Read More+

                          Blog

                          Neymar da Silva Scouting Report

                          Football Spy 11:53 21/03/10

                              Premier League giants Chelsea and Manchester City are set for a summer battle for the signature of B... Read More+

                              Column

                              Why Aquilani is the Premier League's 'Golden Bin' winner

                              The Mole 07:01 21/03/10

                                  In Italy it’s called the ­Bidone d’Oro, the most ­unwanted award in ­football.The prize goes to the ... Read More+

                                  Column

                                  What a difference a decade has made for Zamora

                                  The Mole 07:00 21/03/10

                                      What a difference a decade makes.Ten years ago to the week Bobby Zamora was a Bristol Rovers ­substi... Read More+

                                      Column

                                      Why Mark McGhee still needs to learn a few things from his old mentor Fergie

                                      Ray Hepburn 05:01 21/03/10

                                          There is no better exponent at ripping into his players ­relentlessly in the dressing room, while pu... Read More+

                                          Column

                                          Why the Scotland 1974 World Cup side gets my vote as best ever

                                          Ray Hepburn 05:00 21/03/10

                                              Most of the country seems to have been engaged in picking Scotland’s best ever team this week, inclu... Read More+

                                              Column

                                              I hope the Co-op Final will be close... but fear it won't be

                                              Terry Butcher 05:00 21/03/10

                                                  I sincerely hope this afternoon’s Co-operative Insurance Cup Final turns out to be a much closer con... Read More+

                                                  Column

                                                  Why Abramovich's expensive Chelsea flops are the new Damned Blue-nited

                                                  Michael Calvin 23:02 20/03/10

                                                      Damned United can finally rest in peace.Football’s evil eye has averted its gaze and ­refocused on D... Read More+

                                                      Column

                                                      Why Portsmouth should be relegated two divisions, and managers need to get tough on players

                                                      Michael Calvin 23:01 20/03/10

                                                          Avram Grant, take note. Living beyond your means is just another form of cheating.If we lived in an ... Read More+

                                                          Blog

                                                          Why Beckham has to be the global face of English football

                                                          Mirror Football Blog 23:00 20/03/10

                                                              England fans recognise patriotism. That’s why no one can ever question David Beckham’s dedication to... Read More+

                                                              Column

                                                              Why Al Fayed should get some of the credit for Hodgson and Fulham's success

                                                              Michael Calvin 23:00 20/03/10

                                                                  Roy Hodgson is a shoo-in for Manager of the Year.His Fulham team is impeccably ­organised, improbabl... Read More+

                                                                  Blog

                                                                  Exclusive Lucas interview: Liverpool would be mad to get rid of Rafa Benitez

                                                                  Mirror Football Blog 22:45 20/03/10

                                                                      Lucas Leiva doesn’t play the blame game.Liverpool’s Brazilian midfielder is honest enough to admit t... Read More+

                                                                      Does Carlo Ancelotti now have to win the title to keep his job?

                                                                      Latest columnists

                                                                      The Mole

                                                                      The Mole Read more from The Mole

                                                                      Ray Hepburn

                                                                      Ray Hepburn Read more from Ray Hepburn

                                                                      Terry Butcher

                                                                      Terry Butcher Read more from Terry Butcher

                                                                      Michael Calvin

                                                                      Michael Calvin Read more from Michael Calvin

                                                                      Mark Lawrenson

                                                                      Mark Lawrenson Read more from Mark Lawrenson

                                                                      Latest blogs

                                                                      Transfer news, rumours and gossip from Sunday's papers - Football Spy
                                                                        Neymar da Silva Scouting Report - Football Spy
                                                                          Why Beckham has to be the global face of English football - Mirror Football Blog
                                                                            Exclusive Lucas interview: Liverpool would be mad to get rid of Rafa Benitez - Mirror Football Blog
                                                                              Harry Redknapp: The FA Cup means everything to me - Mirror Football Blog
                                                                                Pictures of the Week, March 14-20, 2010 - Mirror Football Blog
                                                                                  What do you think will happen in today's games? - Mirror Football Blog
                                                                                    Transfer news, rumours and gossip from Saturday's papers - Football Spy