Manchester City spent £38m on Lescott and Toure but all it's bought them is a soft centre

Manchester City spent £38million this summer on Joleon Lescott and Kolo Toure, but the pair look incompatible at the centre of the team’s defence.

I was at Eastlands to see City record their fifth successive draw in the Premier League with a 3-3 result at home to promoted Burnley.

It was blatantly obvious what their problems are - and that is at the heart of their defence.

There are no problems with City’s midfield or their attacking options.

But Lescott and Toure, who cost £22million and £16m apiece from Everton and Arsenal respectively this summer, are not up to the job.

On Saturday against Burnley, Clarke Carlisle and Steven Caldwell, who cost only £400,000 in total, looked a far superior pairing.

It just goes to show you don’t always get what you pay for.

And I think City have paid ridiculously over the odds for Lescott and Toure.

City could have got away with playing either Lescott or Toure alongside a rugged no-nonsense stopper like Nemanja Vidic or Brede Hangeland or dare I say a Richard Dunne.

Then you would have a balance between a ball player and a pure defender.

But Lescott and Toure together are too soft and too flaky.

And if City boss Mark Hughes is still at the club in January then he has to strengthen their defence.

Selling Dunne to Aston Villa for £5m this summer also looks a massive mistake.

As a Villa fan I am absolutely delighted that we got him because he likes to defend and attack the ball in the air.

He and James Collins have settled in superbly at Villa and Dunne has already scored twice.

The Republic of Ireland international represents far better value than either Lescott or Toure, who I think in a sensible market would have gone for around £8m each.

By contrast I was very impressed with Burnley, who I now believe can stay up, despite tipping them for the drop at the outset of the campaign.

There is no doubt they have the manager, team spirit and playing personnel, if they keep them all fit, to comfortably stay in the Premier League.

They may still struggle because they haven’t got the biggest squad in the world.

But the way they played at City showed a lot of character and they created chances galore.

So I will be absolutely delighted to eat my words if the Clarets avoid the drop under manager Owen Coyle.



Which classic football manager are you? Take our test

Follow MirrorFootball on Twitter for breaking news, the latest opinions and fun stuff throughout the day

Get the best priced tickets to the best games at Mirror Tickets.

Win two tickets to see Fulham vs Man City with Mirror Football.

Your comments

Related content

Fabio Capello was left with no choice but to sack John Terry
    Steven Gerrard is too good to get involved in 'cheat' rows, plus why Man City have to earn the right to play
      Why West Ham are not too good to go down, plus why Villa-Man United this week will be no guide to the Carling Cup final
        Stan Collymore's hero and villain of the weekend
          Why Arsene Wenger should keep his mouth shut, plus the FA were spot on in extending Ferdinand ban
            Why Wednesday fans should be careful what they wish for
              Stan Collymore's hero and villain of the week

                Latest opinions

                Blog

                Why I'm backing Liverpool's red men to overcome Arsene's diddy men

                Betting Blog 22:08 09/02/10

                    I wasn't sure yesterday whether Everybody Hurts was the new song for Haiti or the injury news from A... Read More+

                    Blog

                    Why Motty must be a good bet to break his barren streak, and the Bet of the Day

                    Betting Blog 22:07 09/02/10

                        BBC commentator John Motson has sat through four consecutive goalless draws and the only man who cou... Read More+

                        Blog

                        Is this the longest long-range goal of all-time?

                        Football Banter 15:34 09/02/10

                            David Beckham's scored from his own half. So has ex-Liverpool star Xabi Alonso. In fact, he's done i... Read More+

                            Blog

                            3PM Extra: The best things we've found on the internet today - Tuesday, February 9

                            Football Banter 15:00 09/02/10

                                Almost hometime, and here we are again with another selection of good stuff we've found on the web..... Read More+

                                Column

                                West Ham's players should tell Sullivan and Gold where they can stick their pay cuts

                                Darren Lewis 14:54 09/02/10

                                    Personally, I’m getting a bit fed up of David Gold and David Sullivan using the media to justify boo... Read More+

                                    Column

                                    Why the Merseyside derby did football no favours

                                    Darren Lewis 14:32 09/02/10

                                        The only things missing from the Battle of Anfield on Saturday were baseball bats and bomber jackets... Read More+

                                        Column

                                        Why Tottenham's players need to show as much ambition as their manager

                                        Darren Lewis 14:28 09/02/10

                                            One win in their last five Premier League games and just three goals since the start of 2010.Tottenh... Read More+

                                            Column

                                            Liverpool remain on course to be third among equals

                                            David Maddock 11:49 09/02/10

                                                What did we learn from the Merseyside derby, apart from the now obvious fact that it is the most vio... Read More+

                                                Column

                                                I'm quite happy with my Mersey derbies having a bit of extra punch

                                                David Maddock 11:42 09/02/10

                                                    I'm not adverse to a little violence in football, at the right times, as it happens.Let’s face it, t... Read More+

                                                    Blog

                                                    On your marks, get set, go... the race is on for the Premier League finish line - Martin Lipton's big lunchtime read

                                                    Laptop with Martin Lipton 11:19 09/02/10

                                                        The run-in begins now, the fight to the finish, all or nothing at both ends.And while nobody would t... Read More+

                                                        Column

                                                        Brace yourselves Liverpool fans... the takeover silly season is here

                                                        David Maddock 11:18 09/02/10

                                                            Here's a warning to all Liverpool fans... the takeover silly season has started.By that, I mean brac... Read More+

                                                            Column

                                                            Why two wins this week would be the perfect Valentine's gift for fans in love with the Blues

                                                            Birmingham City 10:58 09/02/10

                                                                So... 37 points in February, is it time to crack out the champagne?Following a fantastic win against... Read More+

                                                                Who should replace John Terry as England captain?

                                                                Latest columnists

                                                                Darren Lewis

                                                                Darren Lewis Read more from Darren Lewis

                                                                David Maddock

                                                                David Maddock Read more from David Maddock

                                                                Simon Bird

                                                                Simon Bird Read more from Simon Bird

                                                                Matt Lawrence

                                                                Matt Lawrence Read more from Matt Lawrence

                                                                Stan Collymore

                                                                Stan Collymore Read more from Stan Collymore

                                                                Latest blogs

                                                                Why I'm backing Liverpool's red men to overcome Arsene's diddy men - Betting Blog
                                                                  Why Motty must be a good bet to break his barren streak, and the Bet of the Day - Betting Blog
                                                                    Is this the longest long-range goal of all-time? - Football Banter
                                                                      3PM Extra: The best things we've found on the internet today - Tuesday, February 9 - Football Banter
                                                                        On your marks, get set, go... the race is on for the Premier League finish line - Martin Lipton's big lunchtime read - Laptop with Martin Lipton
                                                                          Why two wins this week would be the perfect Valentine's gift for fans in love with the Blues - Birmingham City
                                                                            Transfer news, rumours and gossip from Tuesday's papers - Football Spy
                                                                              Arsenal's descent could lead to madness if Fabregas calls it a day - Laptop with Martin Lipton